IMMIGRATION
More on Immigration
Many religious people, Christians and Jews, believe in using tough
measures against illegal immigrants.
Talkback: Anyone who oppresses
illegal immigrants is not following the clear teaching of the Bible: "But
the stranger that dwelleth with you shall be unto you as one born among
you, and thou shalt love him as thyself; for ye were strangers in the land
of Egypt: I am the LORD your God." Leviticus 19:34)
"Thou shalt not vex a stranger, nor oppress him: for ye were strangers in
the land of Egypt." Exodus 22:21,)
All Illegal immigrants should be deported.
Talkback: According to an October 2007 CNN
poll, only one in three Americans believes in deporting illegal
immigrants.
Illegal immigration is not a partisan issue; Democrats and
Republican alike support tough measures.
Talkback: Polls consistently show that the
issue is significantly more important to Republicans than to Democrats.
If you read about a really harsh measure that's proposed or executed, you
can almost always be sure that a Republican is behind it.
Talkback: Republicans turn harshly on anyone
who says a kind word for illegal immigrants, even their own. Senator
McCain, a war hero, was roundly booed at the South Carolina Republican
debates shortly after he supported a Senate measure for a path to
citizenship for illegal immigrant workers.
Talkback: The reason illegal immigration
ignites such passions among Republicans is not difficult to understand.
Control of the Republican party has shifted to the South, where racist
views have prevailed for decades. Thanks to Nixon's strategy to capture
the South for Republicans, most white racist Southerners have gravitated
to the Republican party. Nationally, thanks to Goldwater and later to
Gingrich and company, liberals and moderates within the Republican Party
have been purged. There is virtually no Republican left to say a kind or
a generous word.
Illegal immigrants do not pay taxes.
Talkback: Of course they pay taxes.
Whenever they purchase gasoline or a Big Mac or clothes at a department
store, they pay taxes. If they buy a house, they pay taxes.
It's costly to have illegal immigrants in this country:
schools, medical care, etc.
Talkback: Of course it is, but the money a
society spends on children is an investment in its future. In just a few
short years--if the investment is generous and wise--those same children
will become the society's nurses, doctors, carpenters, mayors, police, and
serve in our armed forces.
Talkback: Social Security. Because most illegal immigrants are
young workers, they pay Social Security taxes, which makes the system
more viable. At the present time, too many Americans have begun to
collect Social Security benefits, and not enough young workers are
contributing. Illegal immigrants would help solve the problem because
most of them are younger workers.
Illegal immigrants should not be allowed to obtain driver's
licenses.
Talkback: Preventing them from purchasing
driver's licenses is a classic example of cutting off one's nose in order
to spite one's face.
Millions of illegal immigrants are going to drive cars, one way or
another. If they can't get a license, then they can't get insurance, and
if they become involved in an accident, guess who pays? Law enforcement
officers know that licenses make it easier to enforce laws.
There is no viable solution for the illegal immigrant
problem.
Talkback: Of course there's a solution.
Raise the quota for Mexicans who want to enter the U.S. and
drastically lower the cost of obtaining citizenship. Presently just a
trickle of immigrants can enter legally. Small wonder that many
thousands come illegally. Make it easier for people to obey the law, and
they will. Most American immigrants in the past came when there was
virtually no distinction between "legal" and "illegal." They just came.